Rural Wharfedale homes 'left in the online slow lane'

Public accounts committee chairman Margaret Hodge

Public accounts committee chairman Margaret Hodge

First published in News Wharfedale Observer: Photograph of the Author by

More action is needed to deliver superfast broadband to rural parts of the district, a highly critical report by MPs demands.

The alarm is raised over a lack of detailed information about areas that will miss out on speeds of at least 24mbps – making it impossible to “plug the gaps”.

Maps published by Superfast West Yorkshire suggest areas west and north of Bradford – around Keighley Moor, Oxenhope, Ilkley Moor and east of Bramhope – could be left in the slow lane.

And no information is published for areas south of the city, around Cleckheaton and Batley.

Now the powerful Commons public accounts committee has criticised the Government for failing to ensure residents and businesses are given accurate information.

Its report blames confusion about the data local councils are allowed to release from BT, the monopoly supplier of the main broadband contracts.

And it urges the department for culture, media and sport to end that uncertainty – by requiring openness “down to full postcode level.” That would allow rival broadband firms to bid for Government cash to supply the hardest-to-reach premises in West Yorkshire and elsewhere.

Margaret Hodge, the committee’s Labour chairman, said: “Communities can still not access the detailed data they need to understand whether they will be covered by BT’s scheme in their area.

“Other broadband providers might be squeezed out of the rural market by BT’s actions.”

Last September, Bradford and the other West Yorkshire authorities signed a £22 million contract with BT to extend high-speed fibre broadband to 97 per cent of premises by autumn 2015.

However, that will still leave three per cent of homes that will receive as low as 2Mbps – too slow for streaming most video content.

Around 132,000 premises in the district – 13 per cent of the total – are currently poorly served or have no access to broadband at all.

The committee’s report also criticised a lack of “meaningful competition”, with BT snapping up all 44 sub-regional contracts for the £530m scheme.

That had led to BT “exploiting its monopoly position to the detriment of the taxpayer, local authorities and those seeking to access high-speed broadband in rural areas”.

Ministers have vowed that a new £10m scheme will exploit new technologies to deliver superfast speeds to “absolutely everybody” but no date has been set.

Ms Hodge said ministers and officials would be hauled back before her committee if they failed to ensure publication of broadband data.

Comments (1)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

12:32pm Sun 6 Apr 14

forgottenotley says...

Living in Otley (close to Throstle nest) we seem to be overlooked for new technology. We have a speed of 2.5meg, but the line is also so bad that ours if off more than on. We cannot have a new line because BT say "we cannot climb that type of pole and there are already 24 lines attached". We were to be on fibre by 31 Dec 2013, then 31st March 2014, but here we are still paying for an appalling service !! Surely it would make sense to upgrade the people with poor or no service before the ones who already have a fully usable service ? It would help though if BT upgraded the pole as promised and provided working lines.
Living in Otley (close to Throstle nest) we seem to be overlooked for new technology. We have a speed of 2.5meg, but the line is also so bad that ours if off more than on. We cannot have a new line because BT say "we cannot climb that type of pole and there are already 24 lines attached". We were to be on fibre by 31 Dec 2013, then 31st March 2014, but here we are still paying for an appalling service !! Surely it would make sense to upgrade the people with poor or no service before the ones who already have a fully usable service ? It would help though if BT upgraded the pole as promised and provided working lines. forgottenotley
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree